Filial responsibility laws reddit My questions are: Does Texas pursue financial responsibility for elderly parents from those living in states that do have filial responsibility laws? Animals and Pets Anime Art Cars and Motor Vehicles Crafts and DIY Culture, Race, and Ethnicity Ethics and Philosophy Fashion Food and Drink History Hobbies Law Learning and Education Military Movies Music Place Podcasts and Streamers Politics Programming Reading, Writing, and Literature Religion and Spirituality Science Tabletop Games . However, with key cases in PA and ND in conjunction with the aging boomer population, there is reason to believe the laws will be resurrected as states try to offload financial burden from She has always wanted and sometimes needed my financial help (even when I was a kid) among other things that drove a wedge between us. Or check it out in the app stores     TOPICS. Early forms of filial responsibility laws emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. I am so fucking done. Yet another shitty development in my life- I just found out my state can require me to provide for my Filial responsibility laws have roots tracing back to early legislation aimed at securing support for the elderly. I am not sure it is as straightforward as the person you are replying to suggested. Reply Reddit . filial responsibility laws are proof that parenthood is inherently abusive and coercive Discussion you can be fined or put in JAIL if you refuse to take care of your elderly parents in some states. Filial responsibility laws - awareness I haven't seen much discussion about this here, but it seems appropriate, especially since there have been some contentious posts surrounding this type of topic recently. In other states, nursing homes won't take you if you can't pay, but ones in PA will because they know that they can charge your kids for it. No state requires you to personally feed, house, or provide for adult family members, even if filial laws exists in America as well and is enforced a lot more than Canada. Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. In states and countries that had, and then abolished, filial responsibility, which are derived from the English common-law system, most did so in a way that firmly refutes the idea that the People have tried and failed arguing this. My Nparents live in a state with filial responsibility laws, I live in a state with these laws, and the last state my nparents knew I lived in had filial responsibility laws. If you had parents that made you their retirement plan, please look into your states Filial Responsibility Laws. and International, Federal, State, or local. VA's law is VA Code, section 20-88. Filial I saw that California has filial responsibility laws, and I do not think that Washington does. Pennsylvania, unfortunately, has been one of the few to decide recently that it will continue to enforce the filial responsibility laws and has had judges who have upheld it. reReddit: Top posts of October 3, 2017. Number 1 is complicated. make sure you check your state laws regarding this. 928K subscribers in the raisedbynarcissists community. ” They require adult children to care for their elderly or ill parents, mostly in Some states have filial responsibility laws while others don't. Say a parent lives in Oregon (a state with a filial responsibility law, see link) and can't afford to support themselves. The earliest filial responsibility laws date back to the Edicts of Solon in ancient Greece, circa 594 BCE. How screwed am I? Are Filial Laws (having to pay to take care of your parents I recently learned about filial responsibility laws so I wanted to share this with others who have aging parents/relatives. Given that I have been estranged from my parents for years, I am now starting to become very uneasy about these laws. Family Code [4410 - 4414]). My mother lives in Texas that doesn’t have filial responsibility to her children, I live in Ohio that does. This is messy. Posted by u/Easy-Option7183 - 10 votes and 10 comments Texas does not have a filial responsibility law. I pretty much disowned myself because I'm bisexual and I honestly feared for my safety. Currently 29 states have filial responsibility laws, though most are not enforced. --Steve Huffman, CEO of Reddit, April 2023 Members Online. She stayed home with my and my brother while my alcoholic father worked. However, the one thing I've yet to see anyone answer is how it works if you and your parents live in different states with opposite Filial Responsibility laws. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Collectible Avatars; 27 States have filial responsibility laws. I have caught wind from a She lives in Texas whilst I live in Ohio. But talking to a lawyer would be best! The VA Bar Assoc has a referral service that lets you have a 30 minute consultation for $35. My niece has alerted me that my mother’s back up plan is using her state’s laws, to force my sister (also NC) and I to pay for her living and medical expenses. When I was 18, she left him, but did not divorce, to live with her parents, who financially supported her. Boomer takes offense. Moreover, all the states that impose this duty also allow certain legal defenses. Filial Responsibility across state lines . They will give his mom a bath and call it a water therapy and demand $500 a month for it, the government won't pay, and OP will be litigated over and over. Come for support, come for advice, or just to vent and get it all out. The filial responsibility law in Connecticut is the only one in the United States that brings the age of parents into it. The details/extent of the laws also vary based on state. That means your legally required to support your aging parents . My state is not on the list of states that have filial responsibility laws, so until yesterday I didn’t even know this was a thing. This isn't super relevant since it's not filial support laws that require paying for the cost of disposing of the body, but there actually is a way to get out of filial support responsibility for this reason (Cal. I live in Texas, my parents in Virginia. Basically if a person who lives in a state that has filial responsibility laws like Pennsylvania dies and leaves behind no estate for debtors to collect from, but that person has a kid or kids who live in other states that do not have any laws about filial responsibility, would the debtors located in Pennsylvania be able to pursue the kids to get the I'm in Pennsylvania, which is known for filial responsibility laws that leave people on the hook for their elderly parents' unpaid debts to long-term care facilities. The parent or the county where the parent lives must bring suit. Hello, I was wondering if anyone here has knowledgeable on how filial responsibility laws work in the commonwealth territory of Puerto Rico, and especially the exceptions that might prevent such a law from taking effect in the case of an abusive/neglectful parent trying to force their children to care for them later on. com/packages/pdf/health/NOA/30states. Not for her well-being, but for my potential legal responsibility in paying for her medical care. You learn something new every day; what did you learn today? Submit interesting and specific facts Posted by u/harrypotterobsessed2 - 17 votes and 14 comments Thanks! This law enables the County to recover against an adult child. I’m 32 yo and have been basically estranged from my substance abusing mother for about 16 years. A place to post about your MIL or Mother who is just the *worst*. The rule then was that offspring were exempt from duty of care to their father if he had failed to provide for them to the minimum standard of the law in their youth. reReddit: Top posts of October 2017. He is in NY I have been estranged from my financially abusive Father for about 10 years total and No Contact after a clearly worded email about 5 years ago. The place where people can come and talk about reddit fights and other 24 states + Puerto Rico have some sort of filial responsibility law. They have a ton of financial issues, and I have been told I am the executor in case they pass away. I do not have much, if any, evidence of abuse, as the state was never involved in this matter. 35M subscribers in the todayilearned community. I’m sharing it here just in case you guys didn’t know it was a thing, hopefully none of the parents find out this is a thing. These laws really hit home when a parent incurs an extraordinary expense like a nursing home. He lives in Indiana, as does my sister. I've recently learned about filial responsibility laws, which can obligate children to pay for debts incurred by indigent parents for things like nursing homes, or more broadly make relatives pay for other relatives' certain debts. That's what we're here for. com link or Google Docs link containing the bill in Reddit formatting. Just learned about filial responsibility laws . Nursing homes in PA thrive on filial responsibility laws. I have a question regarding filial responsibility between states. In theory, yes, you would likely be liable. If the parent filed some sort of lawsuit, could they compel the adult child to pay for housing or living expenses? I keep going back and forth. Filial responsibility laws impose a requirement for you to cooperate with the nursing home to get the parent on Medicaid. I live in Illinois. This statute is referred to as a “toothless tiger” statute. Statutes commonly make exceptions for a child who can’t afford to maintain a parent, such that enforcing the law simply impoverishes the child. I think number 2 is an easy no. Old age homes can sue the children of parents to pay up if the parents can't. But if you don't reside in the state trying to enforce its filial responsibility law, it seems like there could be a significant issue with personal jurisdiction. There is federal case law that protects citizens living in non FR states from FR state cases. Filial responsibility laws exist to legally require adult children to financially support their parents, aiming to provide social welfare, prevent elder poverty, and reflect cultural values of family responsibility. However, many families live in separate states, making it I am really concerned because she is in a state that has filial responsibility laws. I'm the SG and my brother is the GC. I've read that Virginia has filial responsibility laws, and while I have had limited contact with my parents I am really concerned about the laws. Posted by u/donotholdyourbreath - 19 votes and no comments 22 votes, 13 comments. " I am not a lawyer but I did read into PA's filial responsibility laws in the past and if I recall correctly abuse by the parent is a defense if you are sued. seq. I would not take legal advice from a stranger on Reddit. Currently, thirty states (Alaska, Arkansas My understanding is that VA's filial responsibility law requires children to take care of their parents. Filial or be an ATM for the sake of surface-level "Motherly love" and to avoid any potential issues of filial responsibility. It also usually requires some sort of court action (or county board of social services in NJ). How can we protect ourselves from becoming financially responsible for his expenses? Are there any proactive steps we can take? While I Filial responsibility laws comments. nytimes. Pennsylvania is the only state where these laws are ever enforced, so it's pretty disingenuous to say that you can't just get rid of them when the other 49 states do fine without them. But I suspect most will try to claim the adult child is responsible regardless of where they live. If your parents were abusive, could the unclean hands doctrine be used as defense against filial responsibility laws? It doesn't seem fair to hold Hello, I’m a resident of Virginia who is estranged and no-contact with my abusive mother who is a resident of Florida. 10 votes, 25 comments. From my limited understanding of filial responsibility, it looks like Texas doesn't have filial responsibility for aging parents but Ohio does. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. In Chapter 816, Sec 46b-215, the state considers a person who “neglects or refuses to furnish reasonably necessary support” to their parent who is “under the age of sixty-five shall be deemed guilty of nonsupport and shall be imprisoned not more than a Ohio. They will try to overbill and put liens, threats, etc. https://graphics8. I have read that these filial responsibility laws are being enforced more strongly, and that there are defenses for adults whose parents were abusive. My dad lives in a state with filial responsibility laws, and Ethnicity Ethics and Philosophy Fashion Food and Drink History Hobbies Law Learning and Education Military Movies Music Place Podcasts and Streamers Politics Programming Reading, Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers Press. My mother has several health issues and a nursing home or memory care facility may be in the near future. Internet Culture (Viral) States With Filial Responsibility Laws States with filial responsibility laws are: Alaska, Arkansas, California, Connecticut, Delaware, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Filial responsibility laws . Debates last 72 hours. Not all states have filial responsibility laws, and not all That pretty broadly over-defines filial responsibility laws. (Georgia’s laws are based on 16th century English law, hence the choice of words). reReddit: Top posts of March 3, 2021. Over 30 states have this. Their only offspring lives in New York, which has no such law. states currently have filial responsibility laws that obligate adult children to support parents if they can’t do it themselves. For example, Nevada only has it if there is a written promise by the child to pay for the parent. "It shall be the joint and several duty of all persons eighteen years of age or over, of sufficient earning capacity or income, after reasonably providing for his or her own immediate family, to assist in providing for the support and maintenance of his or her mother or father, he or she being then and there in necessitous circumstances. I was born and raised in Pennsylvania, which has filial responsibility laws. We are very limited contact with his mother (we haven’t even seen her in years) as she has always been neglectful, emotionally abusive, and has a history of being a drug addict and alcoholic. That’s not really filial responsibility, but rather more a matter of contract. These laws can require the payment of unpaid medical bills, nursing home costs, or other care expenses when the elderly person cannot afford them. If my parents live in Indiana Connecticut. However, the suit was under Pennsylvania law. Arguably, if Pennsylvania state law affirmatively requires adult children to provide support to their indigent parents, and you are a child who failed to provide support to a qualifying parent (as defined in the statute) living in Pennsylvania, then Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Please remove if not relevant, this is a PSA to anyone living in the US. Understanding this historical framework is essential for grasping the current implications of these laws. This is a support group for people raised by abusive parents (with toxic, self-absorbed or Florida, like Texas, does not have a filial responsibility law. My mother has never worked. California has a filial responsibility law and Wisconsin does not. As far as I know he's still tied up in their madness. However, the county is not ever the person providing care to the “pauper” adult. Same with medical procedures etc. States with filial responsibility laws tend to be reticent to repeal them, because they imply either a willingness to throw the elderly into the streets, or a commitment to increasing social spending, and either one is a political live wire in the US. Filial responsibility laws are statutes that obligate family members, typically adult children, to provide financial support to their indigent parents. First, we would need to look to the specific filial responsibility law at issue. ). Is it possible that I will be held responsible for her expenses? If that is possible, Here is the California law: Family Law Code 4400 et. Because it is a niche area of the law you may want to search for a lawyer or law firm now. NAL, but I have done similar research as you. The case eventually settled when the mother qualified for Pennsylvania Medicaid and the nursing home was paid through Medicaid. Most of the discussion I've seen here so far is about people who are caught off guard after receiving a large bill. The fourth amendment applies to protect you from unreasonable searches and seizures, yes. Has anyone experienced this situation within the last decade or so? I’m curious how it’s actively being pursued under different state laws and how it played out. S. what about parents who were abusive and ruined ur life? you’re forced by the government to take care of them. It's not like she can call you up and demand money and you have to pay. Reply reply PM-ME-PIERCED-NIPS I'm not defending filial piety laws but this sounds nuts even for them. Expand user menu Open settings menu. r/legaladvice. The PA Filial responsibility laws provide very narrow grounds to get out of it, basically, parent needs to have abandoned you while you were still a minor. Nor are they searches or seizures in either sense of the word as used in the constitution. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts You need a family law attorney cuz you have legal issues. Filial responsibility laws NSW Australia? NSW Hi all, Just wondering whether NSW has any filial responsibility laws? To submit legislation, please modmail a pastebin. Press J to jump to the feed. From what I have read, it sounds like more enforcement of these laws that require children to support indigent Thirty U. I am currently NC with my Nparents. So her son would be on the hook, not you. A place to ask simple legal questions. Discussion oft Filial responsibility laws do exist, but they are rarely used and have many safeguards, including a requirement that you have the means to provide assistance. Most of the 30 states with filial responsibility laws do not enforce them. Even if your parents were to move to a state with filial responsibility laws, and even if a caregiver were to file suit under those laws, your obligations would be purely financial. Posted by u/Dimeolas7 - 5 votes and 16 comments Here goes: I only recently learned about the filial responsibility laws that are still on the books in a large number of US states. Other states, such as Iowa, haven't heard a filial responsibility case in a couple hundred years. The filial responsibility laws do not apply if the child was emancipated, or the parent was essentially absentee / abusive until a certain age. I'm just curious. This law is rarely enforced. I will practically never be able to benefit from any savings I have in fiat once those kick in Posted by u/madmonkey12 - 5 votes and 4 comments Estranged parent diagnosed with Bladder Cancer, I live in PA where Filial Responsibility Laws have been enforced and want to minimize my risk if possible. My father is incredibly abusive, and I stopped talking to him in 2013. My mother is 59 and also a PA resident. Filial responsibility laws are not "unreasonable" searches or seizures. Now she’s nearing retirement age and I worry that if she moves to CA, she’s going to legally make me responsible for taking care of her. The care provider certainly would have a claim on the estate, but it doesn't sound like there's really much to claim anyway. TIL Under Pennsylvania's 'Filial Responsibility' Law, an adult child (regardless of state of residence) can be held liable for their elderly parent's medical and nursing home costs, with no say in how those costs are incurred. true If my parents live in Indiana (a state with Filial Responsibility law) but I am a resident of Michigan View community ranking In the Top 5% of largest communities on Reddit. But filial responsibility laws are very rarely enforced; 11 of the 28 states that have them have never used them. Im pretty sure only pensylvania enforces filial responsibility laws but youd want a lawyer for that. For example, if she's got $50k of credit card debt, there is no way that that transfers to you - it transfers to her estate upon her passing, and if her The Federal government does NOT have a Filial Responsibility law, which means that the state would have to bring a federal charge or federal civil suit against a citizen of another state, and since there is no federal FR law, there is no jurisdiction. In one Penn-sylvania case, a nursing home successfully sued a son for his mother's $95,000 nursing home bill. This usually means providing any of the parent's identifying info that you have to the nursing home (such as their date of birth and SSN), as well as signing a declaration to Medicaid stating that, as far as you know, the parent doesn't have assets in excess of This is purely academic, not related to any real life issue (for me at least. Hello! My husband and I recently learned that his mother and stepfather live in a state with filial responsibility laws. Trying to warn others about filial responsibility laws. It appears the law is mainly used by nursing homes to sue children for unpaid bills though it could potentially be used for other types of care like mental healthcare. But again, this doesn't help you with duty of interment. Overall, it seems like these laws are very rarely enforced in general - but most importantly (as I understand it) "filial responsibility" laws do not imply you would eventually inherit her debts. Texas is one of the 20 states that does not have a filial responsibility law. Serious Posted by u/sunreyes-y - 2 votes and 2 comments Although, in practice, these filial responsibility laws rarely cause children to have to pay for their parents' bills, a 2012 Pennsylvania appeals court ruled that an adult son of a nursing home resident would have to pay his mother's $93,000 nursing home bill based on the Pennsylvania filial responsibility law. Reddit's home for tax geeks and taxpayers! News, discussion, policy, and law relating to any tax - U. Interestingly enough, the filial responsibility laws are more "threats" than enforceable actions, to encourage the family members to get the person set up on Medicaid and that's it. These are laws that impose, a legal obligation on adult children to care for their parents, basic needs and medical care. Over 30 states in the US have filial responsibility laws requiring the indigent parent's child to cover their public debts and care. Except as otherwise provided by law, an adult child shall, to the extent of his or her ability, support a parent who is in need and unable to maintain himself or herself by work. Early Legislation. I have recently learned about filial responsibility laws. KY - filial responsibility estranged mother advice So it hasn’t got to the point of needing a lawyer yet, but after a recent scare I wanted to get out in front of the situation possibly. States like Pennsylvania are notorious for their filial obligations. If SCOTUS ever agrees to hear a filial responsibility case, I will be taking vacation days Your comment was automatically removed because you linked to reddit without using the "no Not sure on actual wording or support required, but it seems many states have filial laws. So I understand the general idea of how Filial Responsibility works. Do we have them in Australia? Any legal obligations to look out for elderly (abusive) family members? This thread is archived New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast Reddit . See citations 15, 16, and 17 here, for where people tried and failed arguing filial responsibility violates the Equal Protection Clause, People who have toxic, abusive, and neglectful parents shouldn't have to go through this and shouldn't have to do anything to avoid fifle responsibility when it shouldn't exist in the first So I just discovered that some states have filial responsibility laws and some do not in the U. My This Reddit thread discusses filial responsibility laws and how some nursing homes may exploit them. Filial laws require children to provide for parents’ basic needs such as food, Filial responsibility is a legal concept in which an adult child is financially responsible for their parents’ unpaid healthcare costs. pdf. See r/MHOC for how to join! Members Online. It exists it just doesn’t matter. In practice? Filial responsibility laws are not enforced very often. You can probably easily find this out via google too but if you wanna pay $250 an hour for it, do it. How can this be enforced? Couldn't you just quit your job and claim youre unemployed = you cant afford the parent's care? View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. My siblings live out of country. I think I phrased that right. In 2012, a man was held liable for $93,000 due to this. Quite a few places throughout the United States have these pieces of legislature called “filial responsibility laws. Reddit . Pennsylvania has a filial responsibility law. Probably one of the most depressing things I’ve read this year. xnxloeh ctjvqj qecxhbp mgally gaxko ehphomm dfwy krw bytiqgit invzxa